What one is faster?

I have a select store procedure which cannot be change, so I tried to add index in the tables to get a better performance.

My questions is which one is faster? Should I look at the duration? or Reads?
If duration then the 2nd one is faster, if Reads, the last one is faster.

Thanks,
Terrence

Here is the result form TRACE.

Duration CPU Reads Writes
175 32 240 0
62 47 134 0 after change TABLE1, one index to cluster-index
44 31 136 0 after change TABLE1, all index to cluster-index
123 62 27 0 after change TABLE2, all index to cluster-index

reads cannot be compared from one operation to another, ie, one execution plan to another.
presumably the index mods changes the execution plan.
so be sure to run each condition twice, take the results from the second

look at duration for user response.
cpu for system thruput

note that the Profiler reports cpu and duration in approx multiples of 10ms for 1 CPU, and 15.625 for multi-proc systems,
go the sqldev.net for a fix to allow profiler to have 1ms time resolution